Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 121429
Justified Format lost in .docx bullet text list
Last modified: 2013-08-19 05:46:18 UTC
This bug was found in a OO v3.4 running in windows7 and Linux. It appears that OpenOffice loses formatting when importing MS Office Open XML .docx files with bullet or numbered lists. I have attached an example. Steps to reproduce the bug: 1. Open attached BulletFormat.doc document in oowriter-3.4.1 2. Open attached BulletFormat.doc document in Word2007 3. Compare the documents. Notice the justified format code is lost in the bulleted text. Oliver-Rainer Wittmann Fixed a similar bug with .doc files in the Bug 103711 The following was his analysis: The analysis of Microsoft Word behavior reveals that the left indent for these paragraphs are set at the paragraph itself, while the first line indent is set at the corresponding list level of the applied list style. When specifying the new position and space properties for list levels - see specification http://specs.openoffice.org/writer/numbering/NewListLevelAttrs.odt - such a situation has been overseen. The problem that in OOo Writer all indent attributes (left indent, first line indent and right indent) are combined in one attribute item makes it somehow hard to take the left indent from the paragraph attributes and the first line indent from the list level properties. For the WW8 import I will implement the following solution: - In case that a paragraph has only given a left indent and is inside a list whose corresponding list level provides a first line indent the first line indent from the list level is directly applied to the paragraph.
would you please attach sample file into this bug? thank you.
@slacka: Please attach the mentioned document to reproduce the defect.
Created attachment 80288 [details] Justified Format lost This file was made by taking my original BulletFormat.doc (Word 2003) file opening in 2007 and saving as native .docx format.
Created attachment 80613 [details] sample file .doc
Created attachment 80614 [details] sample file .docx
Hello I checked this issue using AOO 3.4.1 and Msoffice 2010., I attached two images one using a document file .doc and second with sample file .docx. with the last one is different that the first one. I'ts the same on AOO 4 and Msoffice 2013.
I don't know if you share patches, but this bug was recently fixed in LibreOffice 4.
Created attachment 81149 [details] Justified Format lost (working .doc) Attached is the .doc version of the file that is now working in AO 4.0.
Is there a reason this is marked "UNCONFIRMED" and not "NEW"?
Created attachment 81354 [details] docx comparison Word 2007 (top) Writer Rev. 1507307 (bottom)
See attachment 81354 [details].